Home > Issues >

In Defense of Wal-Mart



Liberty Links
Bureaucrash
ifeminists.com
The Independent Institute
Foundation for Economic Education
Future of Freedom Foundation
LewRockwell.com
Mises Institute
Strike the Root
Working Families for Wal-Mart

Wal-Mart.com USA, LLC

Wal-Mart Critics
Boycott Wal-Mart Groups
Reclaim Democracy!
Sprawl Busters
WalmartSucks.org
Wal-Mart: The High Cost of Low Price
Wal-Mart Watch

Don't like Wal-Mart?
Bristol Farms
Brookshire's
COSTCO
Food Lion
GNC
Giant Eagle
Gourmet Food Store
Kroger
Safeway
Rochester Good Food Store Co-op
Target
Whole Foods Market



Introduction

It is fashionable to criticize Wal-Mart. Both limousine liberals and statist conservatives bash the retail giant (and free market exchange) while those same critics type on their Dell computers, chew their General Mills cereal bars and drive their Honda Accords. Free market exchange makes luxuries available to the average person and yet most cannot (or will not) grasp simple economic reasoning as they continue to support government force over others.

I divided this page into two sections:

  • The Critics of Wal-Mart
    • Claim: Wal-Mart "destroys" communities
    • Claim: Wal-Mart uses "sweat-shop" labor
    • Claim: Wal-Mart discriminates against women
    • Claim: Wal-Mart censors its products

  • The Benefits of Wal-Mart (contrast with Statism)
    • Jobs
    • Donations - Wal-Mart is the biggest corporate donor in the country
    • Competitors must offer better goods and services to gain customers





The Critics of Wal-Mart [top]
...how ignorant individuals force others to comply with their selfish plans.

Overview
  • Should Wal-Mart Be Broken Up?
    - Thomas DiLorenzo, July 19, 2006 [Mises]

  • The Wal-Mart war: 10 years, $117,000
    The cost to a local government in legal and engineering fees alone for 10 years of meetings on building a Wal-Mart? $117,000, and counting. - David O'Connor, May 5, 2006 [Lancaster Online]

  • How Not to Like Wal-Mart
    Whatever your reason, if you don't like Wal-Mart, then don't shop there and don't work there. And if it makes you feel better, don't live in any town that has a Wal-Mart store. Just don't expect us to do likewise. - Laurence Vance, February 27, 2006 [Mises]

  • Maryland Wallops Wal-Mart
    - Don Luskin, January 18, 2006 [Capitalism Magazine]

  • The Chutzpah of Wal-Mart’s Critics
    The criticism of Wal-Mart amounts to people’s telling other people who satisfy countless consumers every day what to do with their money. - Sheldon Richman, August 12, 2005 [The Future of Freedom Foundation]

  • The Crusade Against Walmart
    The latest socialist crusade is against the Wal-Mart stores. - Thomas Sowell, May 9, 2005 [Capitalism Magazine]

  • The Anti–Wal-Mart Jihad
    - Butler Shaffer, June 10, 2004 [LewRockwell.com]

  • Wal-Mart: Immoral Monster?
    - Joe Blow, January 5, 2004 [Strike the Root]



Claim: Wal-Mart "destroys" communities


Claim: Wal-Mart discriminates against women




The Benefits of Wal-Mart [top]

Overview
  • Supermarkets make life better for the poor
    - May 14, 2006 [The BusinessOnline.com]

  • Welcome Wal-Mart
    The company’s success isn’t built on exploiting. It’s built on providing. Wal-Mart can’t force anybody to work at its stores, nor can it force anybody to shop there. Through relentless cost-cutting and technological innovation, the company offers low cost goods to consumers, jobs for willing employees, and solid returns for shareholders. - Jonathan Hoenig, February 10, 2006 [Capitalism Magazine]

  • Wal-Mart is Good for the Economy
    From an economic perspective, when all the claims are dispassionately evaluated, it looks like Wal-Mart promotes prosperity.- John Semmens, October 2005 [FEE] (pdf)

  • Wal-Mart: A Business We All Can Look Up To
    Wal-Mart is the world's largest business. Its $250 billion in annual sales makes it bigger than legendary giants like Exxon, General Motors, and IBM. How did Wal-Mart get so big? - John Semmens, April 3, 2005 [Capitalism Magazine]

  • Wal-Mart: A Business We All Can Look Up To
    Wal-Mart is the world's largest business. Its $250 billion in annual sales makes it bigger than legendary giants like Exxon, General Motors, and IBM. How did Wal-Mart get so big? - John Semmens, April 3, 2005 [Capitalism Magazine]

  • In Defense of Wal-Mart
    - Paul J. Beard II, October 2, 2004 [Capitalism Magazine]

  • Wal-Mart Serves Humanity
    - Art Carden, July 6, 2004 [Mises]

  • My Name Is Duke, and I Shop at Wal-Mart
    - Duke Heberlein, June 22, 2004 [Strike the Root]

  • Three Cheers for Wal-Mart
    - Edwin A. Locke, February 22, 2004 [Capitalism Magazine]

  • Lessons From An Entrepreneur
    - David N. Laband, September 1992 [FEE]



Donations - Wal-Mart is the biggest corporate donor in the country


Competitors must offer better goods and services to gain customers
  • Small stores try to find niche as big-box stores arrive
    They want to hold onto their jobs, and to do it they have to figure out just what they are capable of doing better than the big-box stores. - Arthur Kimball-Stanley, October 1, 2006 [The Providence Journal]

  • Target Adds Organic Food Line, Racing Wal-Mart into the Market
    The nation's No. 2 discount retailer said it is adding the line of organic foods because of growing consumer popularity. - Alan Fein, September 30, 2006 [AXcessNews.com]

  • Wal-Mart sells groceries for less
    Supercenter beats Wegmans, Martin's and Tops prices in this area. - Frank Bilovsky, March 19, 2006 [Rochester Democrat & Chronicle]

  • The Wal-Mart factor
    To survive in a Wal-Mart world, local grocers, from little guys like Spagnolo to the region's dominant chain, Giant Eagle Inc., are re-evaluating nearly every aspect of their business and working to stay relevant to consumers increasingly less beholden to the traditional supermarket.- Michael Yeomans, November 13, 2005 [Pittsburgh Tribune Review]

  • Retailers using 'anti-Wal-Mart' strategy
    ...in light of retail titan Wal-Mart's success, many retailers have gone on the defensive, positioning themselves as the "anti-Wal-Mart," to stay competitive... - Dar Haddix, July 7, 2005 [Washington Times]








Capitalism=Liberty
The Ultimate pro-WalMart Article
- Paul Kirklin
No Capitalism, No Freedom
- Mike Wasdin
Bureaucracy Can’t Be Run Like a Business
- Sheldon Richman
Wal-Mart Headlines

Books





Video
Site Map Contact Search


Mark Valenti's Liberty Page created and updated by Mark D. Valenti from
September 1999 through